A Shanghai organization has postponed plans to apply to make
fengshui a "municipal intangible cultural heritage" after claiming
biased news coverage reignited a controversy over its merits.
"I was pressured to stop the application before I finished it by
a leader of Shanghai Social Sciences Association right after the
local newspaper, Oriental Morning Post, released the
story," said Zhang Liangren, vice chairman of the Shanghai Life
Esthetics Association.
Zhang would not reveal the name of the leader, but he said the
pressure began after the Oriental Morning Post published
an allegedly slanted account of his application, which he planned
to submit this month.
"The main reason why fengshui faces opposition is because many
people and government officials think it is superstitious," Zhang
said.
Widely practised in China for thousands of years, fengshui is
commonly denigrated as a superstition rather than recognized as a
cultural phenomenon by local government.
Fengshui means "wind and water" if directly translated from
Chinese. It was also called Kanyu in ancient Chinese, meaning a
geomantic omen applied to a building or a piece of land.
Traditionally, fengshui practitioners were usually consulted
before construction or renovation of a building.
"Fengshui is a branch of science, rather than superstition,"
says the application of the Shanghai Life Esthetics Association, a
member organization of Shanghai Social Sciences Association.
"As a building and location evaluation based on geology,
landform and physiognomy, it is an important part of traditional
Chinese culture," said Zhang.
He said applications in other east Asian countries triggered
their action.
Emphasizing the harmonious co-existence of man and environment,
fengshui is a discipline of geography, architecture, ethics and
prophecy based on the Taoist principle that the earth, sky and man
are part of one whole, said Zhang.
Although the Chinese government has never banned the practice
officially, fengshui is defined in Chinese contemporary
dictionaries as a "superstitious belief from ancient China".
Opponents, ranging from ordinary people to government officials,
say recognition of this 'superstition' contradicts China's current
concept of scientific development.
But a survey on Sohu.com, one of China's major websites, showed
80 percent of 1,200 people polled supported the application, while
only 16 percent thought it was too superstitious and commercialized
to be listed.
"I will never stop. We are aiming to restore the good reputation
of fengshui," Zhang said.
A seminar on fengshui will be held in the near future, gathering
as many scholars as possible to improve the application, Zhang
said.
The biggest obstacle to the application lay in the lack of an
appropriate representative of fengshui, said Zhang Liming, director
of Shanghai Municipal Intangible Cultural Heritage Protection
Center.
Although China has seen a revival of fengshui, the authorities
could find no representative individuals or institutions, said
Zhang Liming. Studies in universities were conducted only by
individual professors, while the so-called "fengshui masters" were
just out to make money.
"Zhang Liangren has put a lot of effort into the application for
years. He discussed with me his application last year, but I have
no authority to say 'yes' or 'no' to the application," Zhang Liming
said.
Listing as a municipal intangible cultural heritage was the
first step to world heritage listing, but it needed the approval
from panels of academics and officials on three levels of municipal
conferences, which considered applications, said Zhang Liming.
Head of the municipal academic panel Professor Chen Qinjian,
from East China Normal University in Shanghai, said the main
problem for the application was to distill the scientific elements
in fengshui from the superstition.
Shanghai, with just 700 years of history, was much younger than
fengshui culture, and not an ideal location for the application,
Chen said.
Shanghai had a sound foundation as one of the origins of modern
fengshui studies and further studies should be done to refine the
scientific elements from the superstition, said Zhang Liangren who
claimed to have an academic team of 25 scholars studying
fengshui.
"Most professors studying fengshui in Shanghai are around 70
years old. We fear for the future of fengshui as a real and useful
discipline, which is why I am doing this despite my age," said
Zhang, 63.
Zhang said the study of fengshui would be better protected if it
were recognized as an intangible cultural heritage.
Fengshui is an environment-evaluation system based on the
philosophy of the ancient Book of Changes,
said?Peking University Professor Yu Xixian.
"Fengshui usually leads me to the same conclusions on building
locations as architecture experts," Yu said.
The most famous use of fengshui in recent years was the Hong
Kong Bank of China building, designed by architect Ieoh Ming Pei,
said Shan Zhiqiang, executive chief editor of Chinese National
Geographic.
"Some fengshui experts see the building as a sharp knife shining
coldly in the center of Hong Kong, while Pei designed it to look
like a spring bamboo shoot suggesting the life of the bank," said
Shan.
Connected with creating luck, fengshui was making a comeback in
China "in the name of science", warned Tao Shilong, a noted science
fiction writer in an online forum earlier last year.
The word fengshui was first found in a book called Book of
Burial written by Guo Pu 1,600 years ago, detailing how the
location and decoration of a tomb could create luck for the
occupant's descendants, Tao said.
"Fengshui is no science. It only swells the wallets of swindlers
and raises unnecessary costs in building construction," Tao
said.
His view was echoed by historian Gu Xiaoming, from Shanghai's
Fudan University. "Fengshui contains too many mysterious elements
which separate it from science."
Some principles are just simple learnings dating back to when
the first house dwellers became aware of that a south-facing door
was the best way to utilize sunshine, said Xu Pingfang, secretary
general of the Chinese Society of Archaeology.
The Forbidden City in Beijing and many other cultural monuments
were designed with fengshui theory in the hope of continuing a
thriving and prosperous country, Xu said.
(Xinhua News Agency January 6, 2007)
